Access the ICMIF Knowledge Hub homepage. Members are encouraged to bookmark this page for future reference.

Video presentation

Insurance strategic transformation: Trends, challenges and opportunities for mutual insurers

ICMIF Biennial Conference 2024: Keynote presentation

The global insurance industry is navigating a complex landscape as insurers face a number of key strategic themes and trends, including global volatility and operating in challenging environment; addressing the global protection gap; unlocking growth through innovation; and enabling transformation through technology and talent. EY’s Global Insurance Leader Isabelle Santenac presents the challenges and opportunities for mutual/cooperative insurers based on recent EY research and a comprehensive survey of ICMIF members and other mutual insurers; providing recommendations for how mutual/cooperative insurers can leverage the principles of mutual differentiation in a dynamic market.

The insurance industry is navigating an era of extraordinary global challenges and opportunities, marked by volatility, innovation, and transformation. Key themes shaping the sector include addressing a challenging global environment, closing the protection gap, fostering growth through innovation, and leveraging technology and talent for transformative change.

Adapting to a Volatile Global Landscape

The past few years have been remarkable for the insurance industry, with record profits driven by strong capital market performance, elevated interest rates, and decreasing inflation. However, the backdrop of global volatility presents significant challenges. Political uncertainty, regulatory pressures, and escalating geopolitical tensions are creating a complex environment for insurers.

Increased regulatory scrutiny, particularly in regions like the EU, adds layers of complexity. Measures such as the Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA) and the EU AI Act highlight the growing influence of regulatory frameworks. Simultaneously, trends such as deglobalisation and supply chain disruptions further complicate global operations. These factors limit diversification opportunities and increase costs, which in turn impact pricing and customer affordability.

Insurers must prioritise agility and scenario planning to navigate these uncertainties. Organisations are also compelled to focus on proactive cost management strategies to maintain profitability amidst rising risks.

Bridging the Global Protection Gap

A critical challenge for the industry is addressing the protection gap—the disparity between insured and uninsured risks. Rising risks, coupled with insurers’ reluctance to underwrite certain exposures, have widened this gap. While disciplined underwriting has bolstered profitability, it has also exacerbated accessibility issues for certain risks, necessitating a shift towards innovative and preventive solutions.

The protection gap is further aggravated by demographic changes, such as aging populations and declining birth rates, which increase pressures on pension and health systems. Governments, facing fiscal constraints, are unlikely to act as insurers of last resort. This places greater responsibility on the insurance industry to respond with bold and innovative strategies.

Preventative measures, such as investments in resilience and loss prevention, are vital. Partnerships, including public-private collaborations, can also play a pivotal role in mitigating the gap, though their long-term success remains variable. Mutual insurers, with their value-driven ethos, are well-positioned to lead in this area by embracing sustainability initiatives and fostering community resilience.

Unlocking Growth Through Innovation

Innovation is indispensable for sustaining relevance and growth in the insurance sector. Insurers are increasingly tailoring products and leveraging digital technologies to meet evolving customer expectations. This is particularly crucial for engaging with younger generations, such as Millennials and Gen Z, who often lack traditional asset ownership and have limited understanding of insurance products. These cohorts demand simplified, digital-first solutions and are more inclined to trust influencers than conventional brands.

Digitalisation and partnerships with InsurTechs are driving the development of innovative solutions, such as parametric insurance products, which offer streamlined claims processes and improved customer experiences. Additionally, ecosystem partnerships allow insurers to offer a broader range of services, addressing customers’ holistic needs.

Enabling Transformation Through Technology and Talent

Technology and talent are the cornerstones of the insurance industry’s transformation. The shift towards a data-driven and digital-first operating model is imperative. Investments in artificial intelligence, IoT, and other technologies are enhancing operational efficiency and loss prevention strategies. However, legacy systems and data quality issues remain hurdles that need careful management.

Equally critical is attracting and retaining talent with expertise in technology and innovation. Despite its significant purpose-driven appeal, the insurance industry struggles to attract younger workers. With a substantial portion of the workforce nearing retirement, insurers must modernise their employee value propositions to appeal to the next generation. Mutual insurers, with their focus on purpose and sustainability, have a unique opportunity to stand out as employers of choice.

Pathways to Success

To thrive in this dynamic landscape, insurers must adopt several key strategies:

  1. Leverage Mutuality as a Differentiator: The values and benefits of mutuality provide a strong foundation for building customer loyalty and trust.
  2. Modernise Technology Infrastructure: Robust and scalable digital systems are essential for innovation and operational resilience.
  3. Optimise Cost Management: Effective cost strategies ensure profitability while maintaining a purpose-led approach.
  4. Expand Product Offerings: Personalisation, digitalisation, and loss prevention should drive product development to meet evolving customer needs.
  5. Enhance Talent Acquisition Strategies: A compelling employee value proposition is critical for attracting younger, tech-savvy professionals.

The insurance industry stands at a crossroads, with immense challenges but equally significant opportunities. By embracing innovation, focusing on prevention, and fostering purpose-driven transformation, the sector can not only navigate uncertainty but also build a resilient and sustainable future.

Presenter:

Isabelle Santenac, EY Global Insurance Leader

More information

If you would like more information on the topic or case studies presented above, please contact us. We are here to make tailored introductions to your fellow ICMIF members and we can also share other member-only resources with you based on your specific challenges and interests.

Scroll to Top